Sez Bill: Grading the 2013 Padres

“We’re going to have to stay late again. Of course you know, we have pizza because they deliver. We can get fried chicken, hamburgers with cheese. We’ll need donations. No, really, you owe me money anyway. You don’t deserve the grades you’re getting.”
Jaime Escalante, Stand and Deliver

billcenter_t120In yesterday’s UT San Diego, soon-to-retire Padres beat writer Bill Center graded the 2013 San Diego Padres.

Let’s have a look at his grades, and whether or not I agree with them.

Starting Pitching: D

The development of right-handers Andrew Cashner and Tyson Ross and the promising late-season outings of rookies Robbie Erlin and Burch Smith can’t hide the fact that this was an area that worried the Padres coming out of last season, wasn’t addressed last winter and was terrible through the first two-thirds of the season. Plus, Edinson Volquez and Clayton Richard struggled right from the start.

Can’t really argue with this. Volquez & Richard brought the entire staff down with their lack of expected performance. But, even taking them out of the equation, I would have given this starting staff a C+, at best. Cashner & Ross took the first half of the season to find their grooves. Ian Kennedy, after he was acquired at the trade deadline from Arizona, was Dr Jekyll (good) in Petco Park and Mr Hyde (bad) just about everywhere else.

Bullpen: C-

Although Huston Street struggled early, he successfully converted 33 of his 35 save attempts and gave up runs in only two of his last 32 outings. Luke Gregerson was again solid as the setup man and Ramona High grad Nick Vincent came on strong to supplant struggling Dale Thayer in the No. 2 setup role. Young relievers Brad Brach, Brad Boxberger and Anthony Bass all went in reverse in 2013 after showing promise in 2012.

They were serviceable, but Gregerson & Street both struggled at times. Vincent was a pleasant surprise. Thayer had his problems, but was solid overall. Boxberger & Brach were just horrible seemingly every time they came into a game.

It’s hard to give the bullpen any grade higher than a C

Infield: C-

Jedd Gyorko had a solid rookie season and led the Padres with 23 homers and 63 RBIs despite missing a month with a groin strain. But Chase Headley’s season-long slump and Yonder Alonso’s right hand injury resulted in an absence of power at the corner spots. And although Ronny Cedeno played better than expected, the Padres were not the same after Everth Cabrera started serving his 50-game suspension for performance-enhancing drugs.

This is where I disagree with Center. I’d give the infield a solid B. Yeah, offensively they were nothing much (Gyorko being the exception), but defensively they were outstanding. Even after Cabrera started his suspension.

Outfield: D

The Padres were counting on Carlos Quentin to play 120 games and fell 38 short. The loss of Cameron Maybin to wrist and knee problems turned formerly platooning right fielders Will Venable and Chris Denorfia into everyday players. The outfield totaled 62 home runs for the season and both ranking left fielders, Quentin and Kyle Blanks, were hurting much of the season.

I take it back. THIS is where I disagree with Center. A D? Really? Denorfia & Venable filled the gap left by Maybin’s injury admirably. If it wasn’t for Bud Black starting Alexi Amarista in centerfield seemingly 75% of the time, we might have seen even more from them. And anyone who actually thought Quentin would play in 120 games was just fooling themselves. B

Catching: C-

Coming out of last season, the Padres were counting on switch-hitter Yasmani Grandal to be their every-day catcher. He opened the season serving a 50-day drug suspension and then blew out his ACL. Nick Hundley returned to catch a career-high number of games, but he isn’t Grandal.

It’s all a matter of place-holders until Austin Hedges is ready. C-

Manager: B

Bud Black can manage. He proved that in 2010 when he was named the National League Manger of the Year for a 90-72 campaign. His under-funded teams have played hard, but the Padres must improve to the next level.

For the love of all that is holy, stop starting Amarista in center. I’m giving Buddy a D- just for that. Overall, C-

Front Office: C

Padres general managers have been hamstrung by some of the lowest payrolls in the major leagues over the past eight seasons. That makes it tough to sign free agents and trade for higher-paid players. However, the Padres say the payroll will go to $80 million next year.

I’ll see it when I believe it. D-

Would have been F if not for the Kennedy trade. Josh Byrnes & ownership did NOTHING to improve this club last off-season. And the Padres win-loss record stayed EXACTLY the same.

They’ve got 4 months to prove to us that last year’s offseason was a fluke and that the O’Fowdler Group® is committed to improving the ballclub, even a little.


I know I have more than my share of fun at Bill Center’s expense, but I want to once again wish him well on his retirement from the UT. If I was able to attend that last game at Petco this year, I would have been joining in on the standing ovation with all the other well-wishers.

Good luck, Bill. It was one hell of a career.



As far as I know, no one has ever claimed that the people who respond to the UT’s polls are all that bright.

And here’s proof:


Follow me on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Google+, and anywhere outside of the 500-ft radius set by the restraining order.

You are encouraged to comment using an exisitng Twitter, Facebook, or Google account. Upvote comments you find helpful, and only downvote comments that do not belong. The downvote is not a 'disagree' button.

  • Rick

    I think the poor pitching by Volquez and Richards this year should have been expected by anyone who has seen them pitch last year. Why did Volquez get to start on opening day twice when he can’t pitch well? He has a great arm but can’t keep his head in the game or hold a lead. I disagree that the Padres’ power diminished when Alonso got hurt. He has very little power. Why are you high on Grandal? He is a good hitter when taking HGH, but now that he stopped, his average dropped by about 80 points. Quentin is a fine hitter when he is healthy, but he’s never healthy, so why multi-year contract? Kyle Blanks is the Padres best clutch hitter. The Padres did very well this year when he batted cleanup. Gyorko has much potential. The weak link is Bud Black. The Padres right now have the players to win their division and should have been competitive this year. Black makes bad decisions, particularly about pitching. Luke Gregorson is a fantastic pitcher. He is virtually unhittable when he has enough rest, but he needs more rest than other pitchers because of how often he throws his slider. When Gregorson has sufficient rest, he is the best reliever in baseball. When his arm is tired, he is mediocre. Black needs to give him a bit more rest, to stop overusing his pitchers, and get over his obsession with lefty/righty switches. A manager with better motivational skills and who can handle a pitching staff better could win this division. And Black should know how to handle a pitching staff because he’s a former pitcher. He has never won his division or a wild card. The pads need a good manager. Tony LaRussa could win the NL West with this team.

    • Yeah, well, get ready for another season of Bud Black. #ThatsBaseball

    • Patrick R.

      No way Tony LaRussa wins the West with this team. Managers won’t make the difference, good players will. There is little to zero evidence of Blanks being “the Padres best clutch hitter,” and re: Yasmani Grandal, you’re referring to BA which is a poor indication of true talent level (leaving aside the argument that there is little evidence that supports the efficacy of HGH). Gregerson is very far from the best reliever in baseball, to name three substantially better: Koji Uehara, Craig Kimbrel, Kenley Jansen. I could go on and on.

      I love this team so much, and I see the potential, but there’s a lot more lacking than just a good manager

      • I’m still trying to figure out where I said anything that would even remotely insinuate that I’m “high on Grandal.”

      • USMC53

        It’s so obvious… you called him a “place-holder.” You may as well have just called him and Hundley future first-ballot Hall of Famers.

      • Oh! I see!

        (No, I don’t.)

      • Patrick R.

        Hahaha. It was a pretty bizarre rant, especially because pointing out Grandal’s shortcomings seems to detract from his argument that Bud is the weak link.

    • USMC53

      “The weak link is Bud Black. The Padres right now have the players to win their division and should have been competitive this year.”

      Give me a break. With our injuries and suspensions, and the starting pitching we had for the first 4 months of the season… John McGraw, Miller Huggins, Connie Mack, Walter Alston, Casey Stengel, and Tony LaRussa couldn’t have put their heads together and figured out a way to win the West this year. Bud Black isn’t the reason we didn’t contend.

  • Nathan Veale

    I gotta say, I think Center’s grades are pretty much spot on.

  • Sac Bunt Melvin

    > I’ll see it when I believe it.

    Right, but that refers to the payroll which isn’t the FO’s responsibility.